Blog

Quick Summary

AARP promotes three life insurance policies for seniors through New York Life: term, whole life, and guaranteed acceptance whole life. But are they worth the cost? As AARP life insurance really legit or not? This review pulls back the curtain on each plan, exposing the fine print, risk and hidden costs, and explains why many seniors are unknowingly paying more for less. If you’re over 50 and value honest guidance over flashy branding, this breakdown is for you.

Who Underwrites AARP Life Insurance?

Let’s be clear: AARP is not an insurance company. It’s a marketing brand. The actual life insurance is underwritten by New York Life (NYL), one of the biggest names in the industry. But bigger doesn’t always mean better value.

And to even apply, you have to pay $16/year to become an AARP member — on top of your monthly premiums. That’s essentially a cover charge just to see the menu.

AARP does not endorse the life insurance products, It is strictly a business relationship. New York Life pays handsomely to license the AARP brand. That marketing cost gets passed along to you, the consumer.

• Term & Whole Life: Underwritten by New York Life
• Medicare Plans: UnitedHealthcare
• Auto/Home Insurance: The Hartford

AARP Life Insurance Options at a Glance

AARP Term Life Insurance Review

Verdict: ❌ Not recommended for final expense or retirement planning

On paper, AARP’s term life policy looks convenient — no exam, decent coverage limits. But here’s the catch:

• The policy ends at age 80. If you live past that (and many do), your coverage vanishes, leaving your family with nothing.
• Premiums increase every 5 years, often jumping significantly in your 70s. Most people on fixed incomes simply can’t keep up.
• There’s no cash value, and once the coverage expires, you get no money back.

Many seniors we’ve worked with said they felt blindsided when they saw their premiums spike. Others let the policy lapse due to another rate increase — losing all the money they paid in. It’s heartbreaking.

💡 Better option: Guaranteed level term from independent carriers — same simplicity, but your premiums never increase, more affordable and coverage can extend to age 80 or slightly longer.

AARP Whole Life Insurance Review

Verdict: ✅ Solid policy, but qualifying for it may be challenging for many seniors. Lot’s of seniors are denied and pushed to their limited benefit and more expensive whole life policy. Can be overpriced in certain age groups

This is the best of AARP’s three options — if you absolutely want to stay within their ecosystem. Here’s what you get:

• Guaranteed lifetime coverage (feature of all whole life insurance)
• Premiums never increase
• Builds small cash value over time
• No medical exam, but a health questionnaire is required

But — and this is a big but — you may get pushed to their “Guaranteed Acceptance” plan below

We’ve helped thousands of seniors get more coverage for less — and it’s not even close. Yes, 1st day full coverage. The brand recognition of AARP stamped on the policy by New York Life doesn’t mean this in your best interest nor that of your loved ones.

AARP Guaranteed Acceptance Life Insurance Review

Verdict: ❌ Only consider if you’ve exhausted all other options

This type of life insurance product is marketed aggressively on TV — no health questions, guaranteed acceptance, fixed premiums for life. The most famous is Colonial Penn, hands down. But here’s what neither party wants to make very clear/emphasize:

• 2-year waiting period: If you die from natural causes in the first 2 years, your family gets no death benefit — just a refund of premiums and 10% interest with AARP/NYL.
• High cost per $1,000: You’re also paying a very steep price for convenience (no health questions at all).

We’ve talked to seniors who were healthy enough to qualify for immediate, full 1st day coverage — and no one ever told them. They assumed this was the only choice because of their less than ideal health struggles.

The result? They end up overpaying by thousands of dollars over the life of the policy and potentially placed their family in a very stressful position if death occured unexpectedly.

How Does AARP Compare to Other Carriers? Is It Good?

We regularly compare AARP policies to top-rated carriers like Mutual of Omaha, Transamerica, and Foresters. Here’s how AARP stacks up:

Independent brokers can access companies with better prices, more flexibility, and first-day coverage — all without making you pay for New York Life’s “AARP” stamp.

Are There Better Options Than AARP Life Insurance?

Yes. Independent brokers (like us at Maple Valley Insurance Group) work with dozens of companies that offer:

• Lower monthly rates
• Policies that don’t cancel at age 80
• First-day, full coverage — even with health conditions
• No association membership fees
• Personalized guidance from licensed agents who focus on your best interests

Many seniors never realize these options exist — because AARP’s marketing is everywhere. But better, more affordable policies are just a phone call away.

Final Grades

• AARP Term Life: C- — Limited duration 80th birthday expiration, rising and non guaranteed premiums
• AARP Whole Life: B — Stable but underwriting qualifications make it challenging for many seniors
• AARP Guaranteed Acceptance: C — Last-resort option, expensive for what you get, better options available

Final Thoughts: Don’t Mistake Familiarity for Value

Look, we all trust AARP to advocate for seniors. But when it comes to life insurance, that trust may be misplaced. Don’t get me wrong, their policies are not scams — however, they’re rarely the best choice for the vast majority of seniors. A lot of seniors who we have met were very disappointed particularly in the AARP term life insurance. We should remind readers that AARP sold the use of its brand name to NYL, the life insurance company. AARP does not endorse the products, it is just a money maker for the association.

There is a common mistake many of these trusting seniors we’ve conversed with other the years. They purchased life insurance based on the brand name and the promise of “no exam” — and ended up overpaying, underinsured or worse yet, unaware their policy was not permanent coverage and went up in price every 5 years. You deserve more transparency, more choices, and a better deal.

Their are plenty of no exam life insurance policies for seniors with features not included in any of the NYL options. The “AARP” policies from New York Life reviewed are just three available on a very large market for burial and final expense insurance. None of these in our professional opinion is top tier. With that said, you get to decide if AARP life insurance for seniors is good for you or not.

Let us know if we can help you protect what you value most, phone: 269-244-3420.

Frequently Asked Questions About AARP/NYL Life Insurance